WHY GO: Morning fog envelopes New London CT like smoke from Benedict Arnold’s deadly fires. In 1781 America’s most noted turncoat led British troops on a raid that left this naval stronghold in cinders, destroying ships, homes and shops. A hundred and twenty years later, young Eugene O’Neill escaped his stern father and morphine addicted mother by “disappearing” into the thick New London fog on his daily swim in the Thames River – a block from his summer home. New London is home to the country’s oldest operating Custom House where the Amistad was taken and sold in 1839, our US Coast Guard Academy, and headquarters of the company that makes the Navy’s nuclear submarines. New London also boasts a world-class art museum, Connecticut College, and large ferries that roar multiple times a day to Block Island and Greenport, NY.
While some of the most passionate shopkeepers and landmark preservationists, artists and chefs have embraced New London, far too many storefronts are empty, and there is not one boutique hotel or B&B within city limits. So, for this Getaway, the Mavens also take you six miles down the Connecticut coast to Niantic, which, despite the looming Millstone Nuclear Power Plant, and a dominant train track that mars views and cuts off a tiny Main St. from beaches, was voted Connecticut’s “Fan Favorite” town in 2013. Find out why. (Hint: it’s got one of the most beautifully set B&B’s in New England and a Brigadoon-like river and cove). As a boating magazine destination writer who favors “gritty ports,” I choose to accentuate the positives of this patch of Connecticut – of which there are many. Come here, and it might well win you over as well.
Things to do in New London CT and Niantic CT
DO: Walking Tour Of New London Historic Landmarks; Nearly all of New London was burned to the ground by anti-American forces led by Benedict Arnold in September, 1781. Today, relish the buildings that survived the inferno, as well as other architecturally significant structures from the mid to late 1800’s – when shipbuilding and whaling created fortunes for many – now in various states of repair. Members of New London Landmarks Commission are the enterprising guardians of these jewels, working hard to preserve buildings designed by leading architects of the day; Robert Mills (Washington Monument) and William Tuthill (Carnegie Hall) among other Colonial, Romantic and Victorian Era builders.
VISIT: Custom House Maritime Museum, New London. This granite structure played an important part in the Amistad story. Built in 1833-35 by Robert Mills (who also designed the Washington Monument), the New London Customs House (still in operation albeit with one push-button phone sitting atop an official podium) is the “oldest continuously operating Customs House in America” and has seen its share of riches, cargo, contraband and illegal slaves. In 1839, fifty-three men illegally abducted from Sierra Leone killed the captain and cook aboard the ship Amistad on its way to a Caribbean plantation. Found tattered off of Long Island, NY, the Amistad was hauled to New London, CT. The story of this fraught ship is told in a very impressive interactive exhibit in this Custom House/Museum which also features rotating lenses from nearby lighthouses, foghorns (a school group favorite), and a collection of beautifully preserved diving helmets from the early 19th century. Open Tues-Sun 1pm-5pm daily.
VISIT: Coast Guard Academy and Museum, New London. The complicated history of the Coast Guard is well documented in this 3,500 sq. foot museum on the campus of the US Coast Guard Academy. Discover this often forgotten branch of Homeland Security, take a campus tour and/or enjoy the view of the Thames River. Best Mavens trivia; the Tall Ship barque Eagle was built in Germany in 1936 and originally used to train Nazi naval cadets. It was confiscated by the US after WWII, and has been used ever since to train American Coast Guard cadets. Museum open Mon-Fri 9-4, Sat. 10-4, Sun. 1-4 during school year. See website for summer hours.
VISIT: Fort Trumbull State Park, New London. The last of three forts built on this site, it was obscured by trees and dilapidated buildings until 2002. Now, a Visitor’s Center attracts adults and kids with a real periscope and interactive kiosks allowing history-buffs to build their own forts and detect submarines. And the fort itself – an Egyptian Revival design built between 1839 and 1852- allows marvelous views of the river. Where else can you teach a kid about our maritime past then look outside and see a submarine go by?”
VISIT: Lyman Allyn Art Museum, New London. The 70-year-old neoclassical Lyman Allyn is set on 32 hilltop acres and showcases mostly Connecticut impressionists, art from the Hudson River School and other American artists. Don’t miss the centerpiece of “American Stories” Hall – a powerful portrait of town heroine Abigail Hinman, draped in velvet finery, holding a musket aimed at Benedict Arnold before he torched New London. With her husband away, she took it upon herself to assassinate the turncoat but at the crucial moment missed her shot, as her rifle was not loaded. $10 adults, under 12 free, Tues-Sat. 10-5, Sun. 1-5.
VISIT: Monte Cristo Cottage, New London. James O’Neill purchased this home with funds earned by starring in and buying the rights to the stage version of The Count of Monte Cristo, and it was where his son, Eugene, spent his boyhood summers. Visitors familiar with one of O’Neill’s most famous plays, “Long Days Journey Into Night” will recognize the parlor, set exactly as it is on stage and screen. $7 adults, $5 students/seniors, Memorial Day – Labor Day Thurs-Sat. 12-4, Sun. 1-3.
GO: Garde Arts Center. This exquisitely renovated Art Deco performing arts center serves up a heap of culture to this small CT River town. Coming up – Robert Cray, David Crosby, an Irish Dance Fest and Donovan in concert!
VISIT: Hygienic Gallery, New London. Formerly an ironic “greasy spoon” café, the Hygienic now showcases avant-garde art, drawing a high concentration of pierced and tatted art aficionados.
VISIT: The Book Barn, Niantic. Niantic is home to one of the quirkiest used book “stores” in the country, and in this Getaway Maven’s view, one of the top Offbeat Attractions on the East Coast. The Book Barn is actually three locations – two in town and the largest just on the outskirts, its flagship location and not to be missed. Mo and Randi White started buying and selling used books 25 years ago, and their little book nook has morphed into a 500,000 used book wonderland, with goats and turtles and assemblage of whimsical buildings on several acres. The “Ellis Island” shed holds “Recent Arrivals,” while the “Haunted Barn” harbors Mystery and Horror novels. The Whites purchase around ten thousand books a week (from 11am-6pm daily; just announce the number of boxes you’re selling), and sell most for $1 to $5 each. Open daily 9am-9pm, except Thanksgiving and Christmas.
DO: Rent a Hybrid at Niantic Bay Bicycles, Niantic. Explore the wildlife-rich salt marshes and rich-human waterside mansions of Black Rock Point – a six-mile loop from the only bike-rental place in downtown Niantic. Just $30 for the day. Or, of course, you can bring your own.
DO: Kayak on the Niantic River @ Three Belles Marina, Niantic. One of the most stunning landscapes in the country is so hidden, even Niantic residents don’t know about it. That will change, when outsiders start discovering Smith Cove. Do yourself a favor and rent a paddle, pedal or sail kayak for a couple of hours ($25-$45) or for the day ($65-$105) and bliss out in Connecticut’s version of Brigadoon.
WALK: Niantic Bay Boardwalk, Niantic. Trains wiz by on one side, beaches, the bay, Long Island Sound and the Millstone Nuclear Power Plant are on the other. It’s rather surreal, a singular Connecticut experience, and really quite lovely any time of year. Still under construction, the 1.1 mile boardwalk begins just under the Route 156 bridge in Cini Park and ends at Hole-In-The-Wall Beach.
BEACH IT: Rocky Neck State Park. Roll out your towel on soft sand just under the railroad bridge, just don’t bring a kite. With electric wires above the train tracks, your kite can get caught, leading to an unintentional Ben Franklin moment.
Where to Shop in New London CT and Niantic CT
SHOP: Studio 33, New London. You’ll find unique painted lobster claw ornaments ($22-$50) and other locally made crafts and jewelry in this tiny frame and gift shop.
SHOP/PROVISION: Thames River Wine and Spirits, Greenery and Beanery, New London. Three connected shops owned by Charlotte Hennegan and Fred Argilagos brought upscale sophistication to New London downtown over twenty years ago. The “Greenery” – a pop-artsy florist – specializes in rare Dahlia’s, which are grown specifically for this shop. The Beanery serves prepared salads and sandwiches as well as the stuff made from the “beans” – a variety of coffees. And Wine and Spirits offers an interesting selection from small producers around the world. “I’m happy to show you $12-$15 wines that drink like $50 bottles,” says Argilagos.
SHOP: Grace, Niantic. From soaps to dresses, boots to pillows, this creatively curated purveyor of shoreline goods is a great rainy-day time-sucker and the perfect place to pick up a reasonably priced tunic and a little something for your dinner host.
TREAT: Gumdrops and Lollipops, Niantic. The cold stuff at Gumdrops and Lollipops is some of the most dense, creamy ice cream on earth, and perfect as a take-along to the beach right behind its parking lot.
Best Restaurants and Coffee Shops in New London CT and Niantic CT
COFFEE/EAT: Muddy Waters Cafe, New London. Might well be a stage set for Friends, this coffee house/ lunch and dinner place is chock a block with smushy couches, chairs and cocktail tables. Sit on the outside deck overlooking train tracks, city piers and Thames River. A popular hangout for Connecticut College kids and faculty.
COFFEE: Washington Street Coffee House, New London. A bit off the beaten track, it’s got rough plank floors, a funky vibe, an eclectic menu (BBQ? Goat Cheese Tacos?) and according to some locals “the best coffee in Connecticut.” Open less than a year, the raves have already begun, with some visitors swearing to return just for a Washington St. cuppa joe.
EAT: Captain Scott’s Lobster Dock, New London. Capt’n Scott’s is a New London institution – a picnic-table hotspot beloved by locals and tourists, too. Named after the man who built the Race Rock Lighthouse in 1871, members of the Scott family have owned this really tough to find place for the last two decades, and it still radiates the best of deep fryer New England. Cup of Chowder $3.50, Fish Sandwich $6.75, Oyster Roll $9.95. Open seasonally.
EAT/BREAKFAST: The Shack, Niantic/East Lyme. On the far side of I-95, and a few miles from Niantic downtown, locals flock to this breakfast spot for huge portions of fantastic from-scratch food – the decadent cornbread in particular.
EAT: Café Sol, Niantic. Fresh salads, organic coffee and innovative sandwiches in a casual counter-service spot. Save room for ice cream next door at Gumdrops and Lollipops.
EAT: The Spice Club Restaurant, Niantic. Thai owners guarantee that the Asian offerings at this great new Niantic restaurant are authentic, but skilled chefs assure that meals are way above average.
Where to Stay in New London CT and Niantic, CT
STAY: Inn at Harbor Hill Marina, Niantic. With 16 upscale rooms in two buildings; one with balconies overlooking the lawn and marina, the other with larger lavish chambers and parking lot in foreground of views, you’ll have your choice of accommodations. At sunset on temperate nights, guest take wine to the Adirondack chairs facing the boats and water, or tote a picnic supper to the Gazebo– an idyllic scene. Parking, wi-fi, snacks, soft drinks, baked goods, morning buffet and gourmet hot breakfast in a stately dining room are all included, as are all accoutrements for beach going; beach passes, towels and chairs. Rooms start at $145 off season and go up to $325 for the largest suite in high season, includes parking, wi-fi, soft drinks, baked goods, gourmet hot breakfast, beach pass.
STAY: SpringHill Suites by Marriott, Waterford. If you’re planning a Niantic/New London Trip and there’s no room at the Harbor Hill Inn (or you’re just not a B&B/Inn kind of person), this newly renovated Marriot nearby is a fine alternative. Rates in the $175-$250 range.