Mystic, CT: Beyond Whaling

WHY GO: Of the 2,700 commercial whaling ships that plied the world’s seas in the 19th and early 20th centuries, only one remains: the Charles W. Morgan, and it happens to reside at Mystic Seaport in Mystic CT. After being restored to sea-worthiness, the historic ship returned to the water in July, 2014 and after making its way around New England on its 38th voyage, is back to where she belongs.

Boats on water in Mystic River View

Mystic CT Swing Railroad Bridge open

But seeing the Morgan, and for who knows how long, the Mayflower II, awaiting its “sailing orders” after restoration at Mystic Seaport, is not the only reason to visit Connecticut’s most popular tourist town. You’ll find great dining, a hot new bar/restaurant, beluga whales, historic bridges and quaint inns in this Maven Favorite.

Things To Do In Mystic CT

Mystic Seaport CT street view

VISIT: Mystic Seaport, Mystic CT

This is probably the most touristy attraction to ever grace the Getaway Mavens website, which is supposed to offer ideas about how to AVOID crowds. But in this case, why beat a dead horse? Or, how can you beat a dead horse?  Or, what exactly IS a Dead Horse in the Seaport’s Dead Horse Ceremony? No, we’re not telling you here, but it is festive and fun and involves hoisting a canvas replica of a horse overboard to celebrate….something. 

Mystic Seaport CT Sailors Reading Room

Stroll the 17 acres of Mystic Seaport, founded in 1929 – arguably the best-known attraction in Connecticut – and you might come across the engaging “Demonstration Squad” and Shanty singers who will do their best to drag you into their shticks.

Spouter Tavern, Mystic Seaport
Spouter Tavern, Mystic Seaport

Take a horse and carriage ride, amble around the boardwalks, bricks, cobblestones, and unpaved paths of Mystic CT, enjoy a beer at Spouter Tavern while listening to live jazz, or just watch costumed interpreters at work.  As for restoration of the Charles W Morgan, 250 tons of government-protected Live Oak salvaged from the destruction of Hurricane Katrina in Louisiana, along with White Oak and Yellow Pine were used to repair parts of the 113 ft. 165 year old whaling ship. It returned to the water with great fanfare in 2014.

Mayflower II and Newest Pavilions 

Restoration of Mayflower II at drydock at Mystic Seaport CT

The Mayflower II, normally in its home port of Plymouth MA, arrived at Mystic Seaport in November 2016 and will return to Plymouth at a date to be determined. See photos and a writeup of the ship mid-restoration here.

North Entrance Mystic Seaport CT

The Thompson Exhibition Building, a huge futuristic boathouse-meets-space-shuttle-hangar, opened in 2015 at the North Entrance and hosts rotating exhibits in its soaring halls. The standout contemporary architecture is reason enough to stop inside, though you can purchase Seaport tickets here as well. $28.05 adult, $18.95 child, or $95 for family membership.  Open daily March 23-Oct. 27 9am-5pm. Check website for other times of year.

Two children looking at large white Beluga Whale swimming by

VISIT: Mystic Aquarium, Mystic CT

If you can’t resist the ghostly grace of rescued beluga whales, or the antics of African Penguins, stop in at the Mystic Aquarium, where you can spend a day communing with seals, penguins, jellyfish, and other sea creatures in this beautifully well-rounded attraction that is so much more than an “aquarium.” $29.95 adults, $21.95 kids, open April – November 9am-5pm. Check website for other times of year.

Mystic CT Museum of Art

DO: Rent a Kayak at Riverdog Kayak 

There’s nothing more serene than paddling up the Mystic – past the Seaport and into a salt-marsh rimmed basin. It’s about a 6 mile round trip excursion. $20 per hour.

Mystic CT Museum of Art

VISIT: Mystic Museum of Art

Small, but packs a punch. See permanent and temporary exhibits in 4 galleries. Open Daily, May-Dec. 11-5. See website for other times of year. 

Mystic CT Bascule Bridge

SHOP: Downtown Mystic CT

Make sure to stroll over the bascule bridge, with its truck-sized cement counterweight poised overhead, then join the crowds meandering in and out of great galleries, boutiques, restaurants and the fantastic Drawbridge Ice Cream (see below). While several of my old favorites have come and gone, a couple of new shops have won my business including:

Sage Mystic CT

Sage – for great, reasonably priced fashion jewelry and great gifts. A few people mentioned that Sage reminds them of the beloved Whyevernot, which closed in 2013 after 31 years.

Curated Fine Art Mystic CT

Curated: Fine Art and Luxury Goods. You’ll find beguiling works of wearable and usable contemporary art in every medium at this brand new main street shop. A personal favorite.

Sift Bakery Mystic CT

SHOP/BITE: Sift Bake Shop

Forget Mystic Pizza, all visitors to this tourist town should head to the Mystic bakery, Sift. All I can say is Wow! You’ll hardly find another baked goods shop of this caliber outside of Paris. Owner/pastry chef par excellence, Adam Young, perfected the craft during his multi-year stint at the venerable revamped Ocean House Hotel in Watch Hill RI, and it is very apparent. Wow and wow again.

Best Restaurants In Mystic CT

Red 36 Restaurant, Mystic CT

EAT: Red 36

The hottest thing to hit Mystic CT,  R-36 (owned by the Bravo-Bravo group and named for the red channel buoy), is sensationally set right on the Mystic river in the shadow of the rotating railroad bridge. A slew of bartenders hop to it both inside and out on the deck overlooking river action. Waitstaff make sure they get things right  and are eager to please, but not over-ingratiating.

Singular location and great service are but two aspects of a successful restaurant: The food has to be good as well. And Red 36 delivers. From 5-Spice Ahi Tuna Burger ($16) with wasabi cole slaw – the perfect combo of seared fish and spicy crunch, to Boneless Beef Short Ribs ($33), chefs know how to get the best of contemporary cuisine out to tables in a very timely manner. Located in the Seaport Marine,  R36 is within a few steps of visiting and seasonal boaters and just a few blocks from the center of town.

Captain Daniel Packer Tavern Ledger, Mystic CT

DRINK/EAT: Captain Daniel Packer Inne

Purportedly haunted restaurant and cellar tavern within a restored 1756 Sea Captain’s home, the Captain Daniel has been packing in old salts since 1983. If you’re looking for low-lit Colonial atmosphere and good food, this is your place. Ask to see a supply ledger dated June 1769 – the place seems to have been run on rum. And onions.

EAT: Oyster Club

Mystic’s “Sea and Farm to Table” adds to the non-franchise, foodie bent of Connecticut’s most touristy town. Oysters come from beds a few miles offshore, and foliage that ends up on your plate is foraged nearby.  So far, reviews skew very positive, including mine. Though the menu changes daily (as befits a farm-to-table restaurant), you’ll find dishes like “Baked CT river shad with a rich potato puree, rhubarb- brown butter and wilted spinach” $28.

Gourmet pizza straight from brick oven. Pizzetta, Mystic, CT

EAT: Pizzetta

Yes, there’s plenty of pizza in Mystic, and if you want a plain pie on the go, Mystic Pizza (which is not actually where Julia Robert’s first big movie was filmed.  That was done in nearby Stonington, CT) is decent.  But if you’re looking for a sit-down brick oven gourmet pie , book a table at Pizzetta. The whole place is fun and colorful, and perfect when you just can’t stomach another fish dish.

Pita Spot, Mystic CT
Pita Spot, Mystic CT

EAT: Vivian’s Mediterranean Market. (Formerly the Pita Spot) 

Locals love this Lebanese food place in a nondescript strip mall on Route 1 (within view of Inn at Mystic). Everything here is excellent and made from scratch, including the humus, which begins as dried garbanzo beans and ends up on most sampler plates.

EAT:  Bravo Bravo 

Bravo Bravo brought cosmopolitan flare to this seaside tourist town.   Streamlined décor and excellent straightforward dishes draw big summertime crowds.  A go-to staple for locals.

Drawbridge Ice Cream, Mystic CT
Drawbridge Ice Cream, Mystic CT

ICE CREAM: Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream

Cap off dinner with a perfectly cold and creamy home-churned scoop at Mystic Drawbridge Ice Cream. It’s the most delicious way to end the day, and the location at the groaning edge of the drawbridge can’t be beat.

Best Places To Stay In Mystic CT

Inn at Mystic sign, Mystic CT

STAY: Inn at Mystic, Mystic CT

The Inn at Mystic has never been grand or stately, but for years, this sprawling motel-like series of guestrooms was THE place to stay in Mystic. But by the 1990’s it fell out of fashion, out of favor, with atmosphere that had seen better days. Now, with a new owner, the Inn At Mystic is in comeback mode. Emerging from a room by room renovation, this iconic property atop a hill overlooking the water is attracting attention once again.

Inn at Mystic Room, Mystic CT
Large “All Amenities Room” at the newly renovated Inn at Mystic

You’ll find new crisp bedding, Robins Egg blue walls with elegant wainscoting, eye-catching local nautical photos, large flat-screen TV’s, bedside lamps complete with electrical outlets (a great improvement over behind the heavy bed or absent versions), new carpeting, and wood-burning fireplaces in select “all-amenity” rooms. Walk in on a cool autumn night, and you can smell the lingering odor of a just-burned fire. Rooms from $85-$295 include Continental Breakfast.

Steamboat Inn, Mystic CT
Steamboat Inn, Mystic CT

STAY: Steamboat Inn, Mystic CT

Stay in the shadow of the mechanical wheels and huge cement counterbalance weights of the fascinating Route 1 bascule bridge – book one of eleven upscale rooms at the spectacularly located Steamboat Inn, perched on the most exciting and constricted section of the Mystic River.  (In 2011, Kim Kardashian stayed at The Whaler’s Inn – Steamboat’s sister property across the bridge-which was consequently completely booked for months). $160-$325 varies by season.

10 thoughts on “Mystic, CT: Beyond Whaling”

  1. Just went to Mystic for the first time this Oct..loved it..ia there anyway I can receive the above information…Iam reading this off facebook…thank you

  2. Thanks for visiting my home town! Downtown and the rest of Mystic has so many new things to explore. I see you met Adam over at Sift, his bakery can’t be beat. Oyster Club was ranked in the top 80 restaurants in the COUNTRY and it’s sister restaurant The Engine Room was named Yankee Magazine’s best bar bites for 2015. S&P Oyster Company has an amazing array of our locally harvested scallops, the Daniel Packer Inn has a history that predates the USA!

    I am so proud of our town, and I hope your write up invites more people to join us. My little shop is Mallory’s old sail and rigging repair shop, just around the corner from the drawbridge. The building was first rented in 1832, and there are so many stories in our building. The whole town drips in history and memories from decades past as well as the centuries of historical context our town provides.

    Thanks for visiting,

  3. My husband and I visited Mystic last summer. Probably the most perfect seaport town we have visited. Beautiful views, clean, wide sidewalks, lots to do.

    It is also not far from the Foxwoods Resort. We aren’t casino goers, instead we enjoyed the National Indian Museum. It is ultra modern with great views of the reservation.

Leave a Comment