The Brooklyn, A Hotel: Brooklyn NY

“Don’t judge a book by its cover,” says one reviewer of The 34-room The Brooklyn, A Hotel. Situated on Bed-Stuy’s commercial Atlantic Avenue,  in the heart of Brooklyn, you’ll have to call upon your most adventurous luxury-hotel seeking mojo for this one.

Parking Lot near The Brooklyn A Hotel, NY

Whether you drive in and park at the $8 per night open lot, encircled by barbed wire, at the end of the block, or walk from the A Train station, you’ll be faced with cracked sidewalks, Long Island RR tracks and trains that run down the center of the street. You’ll pass graffiti-laced, deteriorating neighborhood buildings. 

Until you arrive at the double glass front door of The Brooklyn A Hotel (1199 Atlantic Ave.), that is. And then it’s another ballgame.

First Impressions of The Brooklyn, A Hotel

Outside The Brooklyn, A Hotel NY

This is unquestionably, the most disorienting hotel setting on the Getaway Mavens hit parade. Even Bushwick’s BKLYN House is near rising apartment buildings.  But The Brooklyn sits across from what looks like an abandoned factory and car service industrial complex.

The Brooklyn, A Hotel, Brooklyn NY

However, once here, you’ll sweep through the automatic glass doors into a welcoming lobby. Employees at the front desk are known for their friendliness and personalized service.

The space is decked out in modern décor with judicious use of metallic-charcoal leather, chartreuse and chrome.

Lobby, Brooklyn A Hotel, NY

Rooms At The Brooklyn, A Hotel

Hallway, The Brooklyn A Hotel NY

Except for its exterior, all aspects of The Brooklyn prove to be upscale, well-designed and luxurious; a true Boutique Hotel.

Junior Suite, The Brooklyn A Hotel NY

Guest rooms are spacious – junior suites doubly so. Laid out “shotgun house” style, the suite is elongated and narrow.

The Brooklyn A Hotel poem on wall

The sitting room features a 55” flat screen TV and desk with ergonomic chair. A poem about nearby Prospect Park is etched on the wall.

Jr. Suite, The Brooklyn A Hotel, NY

The bedroom is a textural mélange of red brick wall, polished hardwood ceiling (!), cream-colored walls, ecru leather chairs, large floor lamps, another large flat screen TV and soft, dreamy bedding.

You lay your head beneath a black and white photo mural depicting the distinguished monuments of Grand Army Plaza at the entrance to Prospect Park – less than a mile away in real life.

Bathroom, The Brooklyn A Hotel, NY

Bathrooms are Porcelanosa-tile cool. They’re clad in shades of grays and tans, with frosted glass sliding doors, rain showerheads, and modern fixtures.

Toiletries come from Beekman 1802 Farm in upstate NY, an establishment run by two guys from the city who bought a goat farm and became famous on reality TV (we visited the brick-n-mortar establishment in Schoharie NY.)


Breakfast at The Brooklyn A Hotel

There’s no in-house restaurant. But an eye-catching buffet breakfast is served in the morning. Select from fresh-baked bagels, huge muffins, Nutella, peanut butter, cold cereal, hard-boiled eggs, yogurts, juice and fresh-brewed coffee – served on a lobby counter beneath star-burst light fixtures.

Crowd at Breakfast, Brooklyn A Hotel, NY

Five flat screen TVs play different channels. So sit at a metallic leather banquette or revolving bar chair to watch the morning show of your choice.

Chavela's Restaurant, Franklin St. Brooklyn NY
Chavela’s Restaurant, Franklin St. Brooklyn NY

For lunch or dinner, you’ll need to walk about 15 minutes to get to Franklin Street – where you’ll find  a myriad of great restaurants on the edge of Crown Heights.

We stumbled on Chavela’s, an excellent and apparently popular Mexican place festooned with Day of the Dead imagery and funky painted tin ceilings.

I’ll vouch right here for the guacamole, which comes heaped in a traditional bowl, and is so amazingly good, I’d drive over an hour just to have it again.

Just the Facts

34 unique and spacious guest rooms blend texture, color, and artwork. Rooms from $119 – $400, Suites from $180-$550 (depending on day of week and season) includes breakfast, fitness room, and wifi. 

The Brooklyn A Hotel NY Pin


  • Malerie Yolen-Cohen

    Malerie Yolen-Cohen is the Author of the cross-country travel guide, Stay On Route 6; Your Guide to All 3562 Miles of Transcontinental Route 6. She contributes frequently to Newsday, with credits in National Geographic Traveler, Ladies Home Journal, Yankee Magazine,, Sierra Magazine, Porthole, Paddler, New England Boating, Huffington Post, and dozens of other publications. Malerie’s focus and specialty is Northeastern US, and she is constantly amazed by the caliber of restaurants and lodging in the unlikeliest places.