≡ Menu
≡ Choose Your Destination

Marthas Vineyard MA: Island Paradise New England Style

WHY GO: US Presidents and Hollywood celebs love Marthas Vineyard MA, namesake of Vineyard Vines preppie-wear,  just a few miles off the coast of Massachusetts.  And apparently, so did missionaries in the 17th Century. The very first Bible in what is now the United States was printed, not in English, but in the tongue of the local Native Americans – the Wampanoag – in 1663.

Edgartown Harbor at dusk, Marthas Vineyard MA

Edgartown Harbor at dusk, Marthas Vineyard MA

There are six towns and numerous beaches to explore on this 24 mile long by 9-mile wide triangle of land, and it’s worth at least a weekend (if not a whole week) to unwind and do it justice. Inhale Eau de Pepe Le Pew (skunk), “the perfume of the island,” and enjoy terrific restaurants and casual-luxe spots to bed down.

Things to Do On Martha’s Vineyard

Boarding the Steamship Authority Vineyard Haven to Woods Hole Ferry, Marthas Vineyard MA

Boarding the Steamship Authority Vineyard Haven to Woods Hole Ferry, Marthas Vineyard MA

DO: Take a Ferry. Forget flying and travel the old fashioned way. You can catch car ferries from Woods Hole to Vineyard Haven ($16 Round Trip, $137 RT with car), and foot/bike ferries from Falmouth, MA and Quonset Point, Rhode Island to Oak Bluffs. There are even 5-hour ferries from New York City. Savor the trip – you’ll feel as if you are on vacation once you leave the mainland.

TRANSPORTATION: Rent a Bike or Scooter. Or Take A Bus – with several routes, a day pass costs just $7 for unlimited rides.

Indie bookstore, Bunch of Grapes, Vineyard Haven on Marthas Vineyard MA

Indie bookstore, Bunch of Grapes, Vineyard Haven on Marthas Vineyard MA

EXPLORE: Vineyard Haven. A “moist town” (only wine and beer served in restaurants), and artsy, you’ll stumble on the kind of knickknacks that trendsetters find appealing. Check out Rainy Day, Midnight Farm – co-owned by Carly Simon who has deep roots on the island, and Night Heron Gallery, which features one of a kind goods made by local artists. Pick up a bestseller at indie Bunch of Grapes Bookstore – an Obama family favorite .

Here’s an insider tip for celeb sighting (if that’s your thing. Warning – paparazzi are highly frowned upon here, and any expression of celebrity worship is considered overly gauche). Check out Martha’s Vineyard Playhouse on summer Monday nights at 7:30. New play readings draw entertainment notables who show up to support their friends. Ticket $25.

Gingerbread-Cottage-Oak-Bluffs-MA

Gingerbread-Cottage-Oak-Bluffs-MA

EXPLORE: Oak Bluffs. Funky and boisterous, Oak Bluffs is Home of the Flying Horses, the Oldest Platform Carousel in the United States (grab the brass ring!), the largest Black Dog accessories shop (original Black Dog Tavern, opened in Vineyard Haven in 1971), and over 300 whimsical Gingerbread cottages of the Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association.

Martha’s Vineyard Gourmet Café & Bakery by day, Back Door Donuts at night, Oak Bluffs, MA

Martha’s Vineyard Gourmet Café & Bakery by day, Back Door Donuts at night, Oak Bluffs, MA

On a sun-dappled summer’s day, appreciate these colorful works of artisanal construction, and then at night, stand on line for one of the best donuts ever at Back Door Donuts, open 7:30pm to 1am. Co-Owner, Rita Brown, presides over Martha’s Vineyard Gourmet Café & Bakery by day, but at night, a “crew of 10 keeps making the donuts until 1am” and sells them at the back door.

Old Whaling Church, Edgartown, MA

Old Whaling Church, Edgartown, MA

EXPLORE: Edgartown and Chappaquiddick. Well-heeled whaling captains built many stately white mansions along the leafy lanes of Edgartown, and this town remains the preppiest one on Marthas Vineyard.  In the late 1700’s Sea Captains established a house of worship where ministers would lead quick one-hour Sunday services rather than the long-winded ones of other island churches. The 1843 Greek Revival Old Whaling Church with its six massive columns, is still in use and remains a much-photographed Edgartown spot.

Tees By Tina, Edgartown MA

Tees By Tina, Edgartown MA

Naturally, shops in town adhere to the preppy sensibility – Jack Wills and the like. My favorite is the new Tees by Tina, which markets stretchy, hide-the-belly-bulge glamour for reasonable prices. (Clingy Maxi or Mini dresses start at $110).

"Chappy" Ferry, Edgartown to Chappaquiddick, Marthas Vineyard MA

“Chappy” Ferry, Edgartown to Chappaquiddick, Marthas Vineyard MA

Known for the scandal that nearly took down Ted Kennedy, Chappaquiddick is a large track of land separated from Edgartown by a few hundred yards. Take the 3-car, 3-minute “Chappy Ferry” (round trip $4 per person, $6 person with bike $12 for cars), drive about 2 miles (on the only road you can), and at a slight bend, keep your eyes peeled for a small green sign on the left.

Mytoi Japanese Garden, Chappaquiddick, Marthas Vineyard MA

Mytoi Japanese Garden, Chappaquiddick, Marthas Vineyard MA

Take that dirt road to Mytoi, an enchanting 14 -acre Japanese garden with walkways, drooping Cherry trees, wooden bridges and the most vocal (some would assume, happy) birds on earth. It is Zen-serene relative to the tourist ruckus in Edgartown.

Chappaquiddick scene, Marthas Vineyard MA

Chappaquiddick scene, Marthas Vineyard MA

Do yourself a favor and sign up for a special two-hour small group tour of several areas of Chappaquiddick through the Trustees of Reservations. Ride in a jeep or paddle in kayaks to the Cape Poge Lighthouse and other sections of the island, a migratory stop for over a hundred species of birds.

Western, rustic Marthas Vineyard MA

Western, rustic Marthas Vineyard MA

TOUR: Western Part of Martha’s Vineyard aka “Up-Island.” This is the portion of the island that most day tourists don’t see. Bike or take the bus to West Tisbury on pastoral rural roads lined with old stone walls, forsythia and honeysuckle, passing long-horned steer and farm signs advertising “Feta,” and other locally grown and made products.

Island Alpaca cutie, Marthas Vineyard MA

Island Alpaca cutie, Marthas Vineyard MA

Stop in at Island Alpaca. These adorable creatures are used for “Fiber Farming,” and this Alpaca Farm is open for tours (and hugs). Two miles from Vineyard Haven, it’s a quick ride to the lush-lash big-eyed stares of 78 alpacas. With necks like swaying stalks, they are both a tad awkward and delicate after shearing.

Island Alpaca Felt-Covered Soap, Marthas Vineyard MA

Island Alpaca Felt-Covered Soap, Marthas Vineyard MA

Pick up hand-made natural alpaca products in the shop (Alpaca-felted soap $12.50 per bar, hats, gloves, throws, socks and yarn starting at $22), or free nutrient-rich “alpaca beans,” or come just to cuddle the friendliest ones. Owner Barbara Ronchetti is more than happy to introduce you. Open daily 10-4, $5 adults.

Polly Hill Arboretum, Marthas Vineyard MA

Polly Hill Arboretum, Marthas Vineyard MA

Next the Polly Hill Arboretum has an incredible backstory. At age 50, in 1957, Polly Hill yearned to create her own tree sanctuary, and so she sent away for seeds from all over the world. Experimental yet pragmatic, Hill planted non-indigenous varieties in the shelter of hearty plants that could protect seedlings from the mighty island winds. Hill died just a few years ago, leaving behind a beautiful legacy- 40 acres of woodlands and 20 acres of trees and gardens- that can be shared by all. Grounds open all year sunrise to sunset. Visitor’s Center 0pen seasonally beginning Memorial Day. Tours at 2pm, $5 adults

Most of the original Saturday Night Live cast have homes in affluent six acre zoning Chilmark, where “everyone who doesn’t want to be seen lives” (e.g. Bill Murray, Dan Aykroyd), and where John Belushi is buried. Chilmark is also the “Birthplace of American Sign Language” – born of necessity. In the 1700’s through the end of the 1800’s, one in three people here were deaf.

If you’re biking the 18 miles (each way) from Vineyard Haven, stop in with others for a surprisingly good pizza at the Chilmark General Store before heading to Aquinnah (formerly Gay Head), owned by the local Native American tribe of that name. Stop in at the Aquinnah Cultural Center open Memorial Day to Labor Day to explore Wampanoag history (open Wed, Fri, Sat. 11-4)

Gay Head Lighthouse, Aquinnah, Marthas Vineyard MA

Gay Head Lighthouse, Aquinnah, Marthas Vineyard MA

You’ll want to capture the grandeur of a sunset from either the red brick Gay Head Lighthouse (which, due to extreme erosion, is on the country’s list of “Most Endangered Historic Places” and is in imminent risk of falling into the sea unless it is moved back immediately),  or from the spectacular terra cotta colored clay Gay Head Cliffs overlook. You’ll find locally fashioned purple and white “wampum” jewelry, sculpted from Quahog shells at Stony Creek Gifts right on the path to the overlook. These are authentic, but beware of the hawkers of “Indian Bead Necklaces” made in China.

Aquinnah/Gay Head Cliffs, Marthas Vineyard MA

Aquinnah/Gay Head Cliffs, Marthas Vineyard MA

The land you see offshore belong to the string of 16 Elizabeth Islands that extend from here to Cape Cod, the largest of which is Cuttyunk, a speck of oyster-farmers, fishing charters and scrub-brush with 49 full-time residents. From there, the next landmass is Ireland.

Larsen's Fish Market Chowder picnic, Menemsha - Marthas Vineyard MA

Larsen’s Fish Market Chowder picnic, Menemsha – Marthas Vineyard MA

For some of the freshest off-the-boat seafood, peddle over to Menemsha, the poster-perfect New England fishing village, which also made an appearance in the movie, Jaws. Both Larsen’s Fish Market and Menemsha Fish Market are good bets. There’s no place to sit inside these fresh seafood markets, so order your stuffed or steamed clams, lobster and broth-like chowder, then take your meal to the docks out back, hard by the rusted clamming boats. Alternately, walk a block to the beach for yet another unbeatable sunset, then go home – just one more perfect day on the Vineyard.

Best Places to Eat on Marthas Vineyard MA

EAT/BREAKFAST: Water Street at Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown. “ ½ doz. Good Morning Oysters with Bloody Mary” ($17) and Ricotta Blintzes dollopped with Blackberry Sorbet, Hazelnuts and maple syrup ($10) join other morning offerings that are more inventive and well-prepared than those of most hotel restaurants.

EAT: Henry’s at Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown. Two words: Kimchi Burger. I broke my beef hamburger fast for this and it was well worth it. Add a side of Parmesan Truffle fries to anything you order. You’ll get good advice on wine and beer pairings with inspired pub food from the attentive and helpful wait-staff.

Crabmeat Guacamole, Atlantic Restaurant, Edgartown Marthas Vineyard MA

Crabmeat Guacamole, Atlantic Restaurant, Edgartown Marthas Vineyard MA

EAT: Atlantic Fish and Chop House, Edgartown. Right on the Edgartown docks, great seafood, basic and delicious, is enhanced by stunning harbor sunsets. Order the New England seaside version of Guacamole – with crabmeat – and you might just have to order a second one five minutes later.

Sweet Potato Fries, Lookout Tavern, Oak Bluffs Marthas Vineyard MA

Sweet Potato Fries, Lookout Tavern, Oak Bluffs Marthas Vineyard MA

EAT/SCENE: Lookout Tavern, Oak Bluffs. This back-deck like restaurant/bar looks out over the Oak Bluffs ferry landing, and overflows with bar crawlers each warm evening. By day, you’ll be sober enough to appreciate the double-crisped Sweet Potato Fries and pretty decent sushi ($17-$24 for 3-roll special Maki Combos).

Offshore Ale, Oak Bluffs: Marthas Vineyard MA

Offshore Ale, Oak Bluffs: Marthas Vineyard MA

DRINK: Offshore Ale, Oak Bluffs. Grab a handful of peanuts in the shell, then sample a variety of house-brewed beer. Feel good about imbibing here – every pint helps to support the Coast Guard Foundation.

Where to Stay on Marthas Vineyard

View from the front porch of Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown MA

View from the front porch of Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown MA

STAY: Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown. You can pitch a tent on this exquisite site and be happy. But the recently refurbished Harbor View is of course far from camping or even glamping, and has risen to the level of luxury/casual “Beachy Chic.” The Edgartown Lighthouse, a dancer’s leap from the Inn’s wide whitewashed wraparound porch (complete with rocking chairs), glows in the setting sun while boats return to harbor.

Waterfront suite, Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown: Marthas Vineyard MA

Waterfront suite, Harbor View Hotel, Edgartown: Marthas Vineyard MA

Ask for a sizable, beautifully designed Harbor View room in the main building (about $600/night in season includes small deck), and you don’t even have to leave your chamber for outstanding pink sunrises and golden sunsets.

Sunrise view over Edgartown Light from Harbor View Hotel room, Edgartown MA

Sunrise view over Edgartown Light from Harbor View Hotel room, Edgartown MA

For now, spacious bathrooms are “vintage” – with original tub showers, so if you require a subway tile shower, mosaic floor and ultra-stylish bath in lieu of view, book a suite, which includes a knock-out bathroom, galley kitchen and sitting room (and will run you about $1600 per night in season) in the more private Captain’s Quarters, a series of Garden-Set townhomes behind the main building. Rooms and Suites from $190 (midweek-offseason) to $1900 (suite, summer weekend), with most in the $500-$600 range in summer.

Charlotte Inn, Edgartown: Marthas Vineyard MA

Charlotte Inn, Edgartown: Marthas Vineyard MA

STAY/EAT: The Charlotte Inn, Edgartown. Two golden retrievers greet you at the door of the only Relais & Chateaux property on Martha’s Vineyard. On a side street, it doesn’t offer water-views, but if you wish to vacation like a 19th century whaling captain, this is the place. Enter into what amounts to an intimate art museum. Exquisite rooms showcase English antiques. Relish American cuisine with French and Italian influence at one of the best (albeit pricey) restaurants on the island, The Terrace. Set within an enclosed conservatory it is “a stunning dining experience,” according to many guests. Rooms $350 and up per night.

Isabelle's Beach House, Oak Bluffs: Marthas Vineyard MA

Isabelle’s Beach House, Oak Bluffs: Marthas Vineyard MA

STAY: Isabelle’s Beach House B&B, Oak Bluffs. Across the street from Oak Bluffs Beach, this Victorian-era waterfront guesthouse is as cheerful, friendly and as easy-peasy-breezy as it gets. Rates for pretty, pleasant rooms are relatively reasonable for the island – ranging from $150 offseason to the low-$300’s (with three night minimum) in the summer. All include afternoon snacks, hot breakfast buffet and unlimited views of Vineyard Sound.

For last minute lodging ideas and deals, check out mvy.co

{ 2 comments… add one }

  • Astrid February 23, 2017, 3:20 am

    Even although it’s dropped from second to third place, I can see why Martha’s Vineyard is still in the top 3 of the most popular towns in North East America.

    Since reading your top 20 list I’ve done some more research and it’s definitely a place I’d love to visit. I’m not too phased about the fact that the rich and famous love it – but I understand why. I’m more interested in the beauty and history of the place.
    Astrid recently posted…Best Water Filtration System For SurvivalMy Profile

    • Malerie Yolen-Cohen February 25, 2017, 7:33 am

      MV is one of my favorite places – and has been since I was a kid. Thanks so much for reading and commenting! Malerie

Cancel reply

Leave a Comment

CommentLuv badge

Subscribe

Click here to Subscribe to the Getaway Mavens Newsletter

Get In Touch